Murphy Business Sales - RaleighBizNexusPartner Network member

Murphy Business Sales - Raleigh · Owner briefing

How to Respond to the First Offer on Your Business

Don Emmett
Don Emmett
November 16, 2026 · 5 min read

Don Emmett is a Certified Business Intermediary and Certified Exit Planner at Murphy Business Sales - Raleigh, an independent business brokerage focused on owner-operated companies across the Raleigh-Durham-Chapel Hill area. Murphy Business Sales - Raleigh is a member of the BizNexus Partner Network, which publishes its owner briefings.

Respond to the first offer on your business by reading the whole offer before the price, asking the buyer questions before you counter, and keeping other buyer conversations going. Then counter in writing on the two or three terms that matter most to you, and settle the big points before signing an exclusive letter of intent.

The first written offer on your business is a good day. Someone has looked closely at what you built and decided they want it enough to put a number on paper. How you respond in the next week or two shapes much of what follows, and a calm, organized response almost always leads to a better deal than a fast yes or a fast no.

1. Read the whole offer before you read the price

Most owners look at the number first, and that is natural. But two offers with the same price can leave you with very different amounts in your pocket and very different years after closing.

Read every part of it. How much is paid in cash at closing, and how much later through a seller note or an earnout tied to future results? What exactly is included: equipment, vehicles, inventory, the name, the phone number? How will inventory and working capital be counted on the closing date? How long does the buyer want you to stay, and in what role? What has to happen before they close, and by when? Once you see all of it in one place, the price becomes one term among several, which is what it really is.

2. Ask questions before you counter

An offer tells you what a buyer wants. Questions tell you why, and the why is where your room to negotiate is found.

An individual buyer will usually be borrowing much of the price, so ask how they plan to finance it, whether they have spoken with a lender, and how much of their own money is going in. Ask why this business, and what they plan to change in the first year. A strategic corporate buyer, a larger company in your trade or a neighboring one, has different answers to give. Ask what part of your business matters most to them, who inside their company has to approve the deal, and what happens to your employees and your name. A financial buyer or investment fund will want to explain who will run the business after you step back.

From the years I spent buying businesses of my own, I can tell you a serious buyer is glad to answer these questions. A buyer who will not is telling you something too.

3. Keep the other conversations going

A first offer is most useful when you can compare it with something. If other buyers are still reviewing your business, keep those conversations moving at their normal pace. You do not need to tell anyone what the first offer says, and you should not stop the process because one buyer moved first.

This is not about playing buyers against each other. It is about giving yourself a real choice. An offer weighed against another offer, or against the interest still building elsewhere, is much easier to judge than an offer on its own.

4. Counter on what matters most to you

Before you respond, decide which two or three terms matter most. For some owners it is the cash at closing. For others it is the length of the transition, keeping the team intact, a closing date that fits a retirement plan, or the size of the seller note. Write them down, in order.

Then counter on those, in writing, with a short reason for each. "We need more of the price at closing because the business is my retirement" is easier for a buyer to work with than a bare number. Let the smaller points go, or trade them. A buyer who sees you are reasonable on what matters less tends to move further on what matters more.

5. Settle the big points before you sign a letter of intent

The back-and-forth after a first offer is your best chance to shape the deal, because the buyer is still competing for it. Once you sign a letter of intent, most buyers ask for a period of exclusivity, and that changes the conversation, as we covered in an earlier piece on what you give up when you sign one.

So use this stage well. Agree on the price, how it is paid, how inventory and working capital will be handled, your role after closing and the timeline before you go exclusive. The letter of intent should record a deal you have already shaped, not leave the important parts for later.

The takeaway

A first offer is a starting point and a good sign. Read every term, not just the price. Ask the buyer why before you tell them no. Keep other conversations moving so you have something to compare. Counter in writing on the few terms that matter most to you, and settle them before you sign anything exclusive. Handled that way, the first offer is often the beginning of the right deal, on your terms.

FAQ

Questions practitioners actually ask

Should I accept the first offer on my business if it is close to my asking price?
Not without reading the full terms. An offer near your asking price can still carry a large seller note, a long transition or conditions that move money out of closing. Compare the whole package with what matters to you, and with other interest if you have it.
How long should I take to respond to an offer?
Long enough to read it carefully, ask the buyer your questions and talk it through with your advisors, usually several days to a couple of weeks. Let the buyer know you are reviewing it so the silence is not misread.
Is it a bad sign if a buyer's first offer is low?
Not necessarily. Some buyers open low expecting a counter, and some simply have not seen the full picture yet. Ask how they arrived at their number. Their answer often shows what information would change it.

The Monthly Owner Briefing

Get briefings like this in your inbox

One email a month from Murphy Business Sales - Raleigh. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.

Subscribe free