IBEX Business ExchangeBizNexusPartner Network member

IBEX Business Exchange · Owner briefing

Five Mistakes Owners Make in Their First Conversations With a Buyer

Jeff Elder
Jeff Elder
November 16, 2026 · 4 min read

Jeff Elder is a Senior Advisor at IBEX Business Exchange, an independent M&A advisory firm focused on manufacturing, service and distribution companies in Texas. IBEX Business Exchange is a member of the BizNexus Partner Network, which publishes its owner briefings.

The first conversations with an interested buyer shape the whole sale. The common mistakes are naming a price before the buyer has made a case, sharing sensitive detail too early, promising growth the numbers cannot support, letting figures change between conversations, and never asking how the buyer will pay or what it plans for your people.

Most owners prepare carefully for the parts of a sale they can see coming: the valuation, the letter of intent, the closing. The first few conversations with an interested buyer get much less thought, because they feel informal. A phone call, a lunch, a tour. They are not informal to the buyer. By the end of them, the buyer has formed a view of the company, the owner and the price, and that view is hard to move later. Here are five mistakes that come up again and again in those early conversations, and how different buyers read each one.

1. Answering "what do you want for it?" with a number

It is usually the first real question, and it is asked early on purpose. A number given before the buyer has seen anything becomes the ceiling of the negotiation, not the floor. If it is too high, a good buyer may simply stop calling. If it is too low, nobody will tell you. The better answer is that you want to understand how they would value the company and what they would pay for, and that you will judge offers on price and terms together. A private equity group expects that answer and respects it. A competitor may push harder for a figure, because it already thinks it knows what your business is worth to it. That is exactly why it should make the case first.

2. Handing over the details before the buyer has earned them

Owners who are proud of their company tend to share too much, too soon: customer names, margins by account, what the key people are paid. Sensitive information should come out in stages, behind a confidentiality agreement, as the buyer shows it is serious. Summary figures first. Detail after real interest is on paper. Customer and employee names last, often not until after a letter of intent. This matters most with a competitor, who could use your customer list whether or not it ever buys. A financial buyer or a foreign acquirer has less use for that detail, but the same order still protects you if the conversation goes nowhere.

3. Telling a growth story the numbers cannot carry

It is natural to talk about what the company could do next year. The trouble is that a buyer writes it down. A forecast an owner offers casually in a first meeting tends to come back as the benchmark the buyer measures you against during diligence, and sometimes as the target in an earnout you then have to hit to get paid. Talk about growth you can point to: signed work, customers already expanding, capacity already in place. A private equity group in particular will build its model from your words, so say only what you would be comfortable seeing in it.

4. Letting the numbers change from one conversation to the next

An owner who gives one revenue figure at lunch and a different one in the first set of financials has not necessarily done anything wrong. Maybe one included a related business, or one was this year and one last. But the buyer does not know that. Every number that moves tells a buyer's financial people to check everything else twice. Before the first conversation, settle on one set of figures for the last three years and the year to date, with your add-backs listed and explained, and use them every time. Consistency is one of the cheapest ways to look credible, and it is the thing an analyst on the buyer's side notices first.

5. Not asking the buyer anything

The early conversations are an interview in both directions, and owners often forget their half. Ask how the buyer would pay for the deal: its own funds, a bank, an investor it still has to persuade. Ask what it has bought before and whether those deals closed. Ask what it would plan for your people and your location. A buyer with a clear answer to all three is worth more of your time than one with a higher number and vague answers. Family groups and individual buyers often depend on outside financing, so the first question matters most there. With a foreign acquirer, ask who beyond the person across the table has to approve.

The takeaway

The first conversations with a buyer are not small talk. Hold back the price until the buyer has made its case, release information in stages, talk about growth you can prove, keep one consistent set of numbers, and spend as much effort learning about the buyer as it spends learning about you. An owner who handles those early meetings well starts the formal process with leverage instead of trying to win it back.

FAQ

Questions practitioners actually ask

Should I talk to a buyer who calls before I have an advisor?
There is no harm in listening, but keep the first call short and general. Do not share financials or name a price. Taking a little time to prepare, and to decide whether you want a process with more than one buyer, costs you very little.
Do I need a confidentiality agreement before I share anything?
Before you share anything that is not public, yes. General conversation about the industry and your interest in a sale is fine without one. Financial statements, customer information and employee details should wait until one is signed.
What if the buyer insists on a price before going further?
You can give a sense of how you think about value without giving a number, for example what the business earns and what you expect a buyer to pay for. A serious buyer will make an offer from its own analysis. One that will not move without your number first is often testing how much you know.

The Monthly Owner Briefing

Get briefings like this in your inbox

One email a month from IBEX Business Exchange. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.

Subscribe free